From the Desk of Lynn Davis, Interim Executive Director
Earlier this month, Tucson Spotlight reported on a local estate sale that listed Nazi memorabilia, advertised as a “German WWII history collection.” A Jewish shopper whose grandmother survived the Holocaust saw the listing and spoke up. I was grateful to be asked for my thoughts. The questions the reporters raised are ones we hear often, so I want to share how we approach these objects at TJMHC, and what we hope you will do if you ever come across them.
“Nazi-era” is not the same as “Nazi”
I would first distinguish between “Nazi-era” and “Nazi” artifacts. Our Holocaust center is largely narrative-based, built around the stories of the 270+ survivors who settled in Tucson and Southern Arizona after WWII. The artifacts we have on display are “Nazi-era,” like a People’s Radio that the Third Reich used to spread propaganda into German homes, and a yellow Star of David that one of our local survivors wore sewn onto his clothing as a child, marking him as a Jew.
We chose these artifacts because they help us teach the lessons of the Holocaust and the horrors of antisemitism. We’ve made the deliberate choice not to include Nazi artifacts, like swastikas and SS uniforms, because they can be triggering to people who lived through, or whose families experienced, state-sponsored terror. We have other, more effective ways to talk about what happens when identity-based persecution goes unchecked.
Why context matters
Context is everything. If a reputable museum has Nazi items on display, it reflects deliberate decision-making, in conversation with educators, a curatorial team, and even a board of directors. Context helps visitors learn how these objects were used to advance a political agenda, how they served as tools of subjugation and terror, and why they remain such powerful symbols, even today.
When these objects are removed from their historical context, they can take on an entirely different meaning. What was once an instrument of persecution or propaganda can become a collectible, a status symbol, or even an object of admiration. That transformation is deeply troubling. The danger isn’t simply that someone might buy an artifact. It’s that the history, the victims, and the human consequences become secondary to the object itself.
Why it matters now
October 7th, 2023, was the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust. In the three years since the Hamas terror attacks, we’ve seen a rise in antisemitism across the globe, including terrible acts of violence and murder right here in the U.S. In an increasingly polarized political and cultural climate, we’re concerned about rising antisemitism on campuses, both K-12 and colleges; in online spaces, especially as it’s fueled by AI chatbots and algorithms; and in the workplace. Having Nazi artifacts on the open market can only add fuel to the fire. They risk being fetishized, glorified, and worshipped in ways that are both dangerous and inappropriate.
How we care for donated items
We do receive donations of Nazi-era materials and other objects related to the Holocaust. We consider each potential donation in terms of its historical relevance, provenance, and educational value. Items we accept are cataloged, documented, and properly preserved. Importantly, accepting an object does not mean we intend to display it. Some objects are better kept in our collections and used strictly for research or educational purposes. Our responsibility is to make sure these materials are preserved and handled with historical integrity and respect for the people whose lives they affected.
Museums also have an ethical responsibility to consider provenance, meaning where objects came from, including whether they may have been stolen or confiscated from Jewish families during the Holocaust.
If you find these items in an estate
If your family discovers items like these, I encourage you to pause before putting them up for sale. Take photographs, document any information that comes with the object, and contact a reputable Holocaust museum or historical institution. There may be important provenance or historical information that isn’t immediately apparent. Museums can help determine whether an object has educational or historical value and advise on next steps.
Call us if you’re in Tucson, reach out to the Cutler-Plotkin Center in Phoenix, or contact the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C. When you donate these items to a museum, you know they will be cared for appropriately; they won’t be celebrated, and they can do their part to help tell one of the darkest stories in human history.
The human cost
Seeing these items for sale should be triggering for all of us, for anyone with a shred of humanity. For survivors and their families, these aren’t simply historical objects. They’re symbols of a murderous regime. They’re reminders of parents and siblings who were murdered, families who were torn apart, and lives that were changed forever.
The survivors still with us were small children during the Holocaust. Their memories loom large, and often, as they age, the horrifying events of their childhoods return with a vengeance. How would it feel to see the insignia from the uniform of a soldier who ripped you from your mother’s arms offered at an estate sale? It’s horrifying to think about.
Putting a price tag on an instrument of persecution can feel like one more indignity imposed on those who suffered. We have an obligation to remember the victims and honor the survivors, not turn the symbols of their suffering into collectibles.